Effects of Winning a Sports Match on Emotional Duration and Work Performance in Adolescent Supporters During the Post-Competition Period

Authors:

Dondoladze K., Miraleyeva A.

Place of work:

  • European University, Tbilisi, Georgia
  • Marat Ospanov West Kazakhstan Medical University, Aktobe, Kazakhstan
  • Reference link :

    Dondoladze K. Miraleyeva A. Effects of Winning a Sports Match on Emotional Duration and Work Performance in Adolescent Supporters During the Post-Competition Period. Gylym Aliansy. 2024; 01

    Abstract
    Full text
    Authors
    List of references
    Additional files

    Keywords:Emotional state, work capacity, motivation, youth development, spectator behavior, sports psychology
    Purpose: This study examines the influence of football match outcomes on the emotional states, work capacity, and motivation of children across different age groups, particularly in the context of Georgia's historic qualification for the European Championship in 2024. Recognizing the multifaceted impact of sports on mood and cognition, we explore how the euphoria resulting from a win can vary significantly based on age.
    Methods:A survey involving 40 school-aged children (11-17 years old) was conducted a week after Georgia’s victory against Greece, measuring emotional responses and their subsequent effects on work performance and motivation.
    Results:Children aged 11 to 13 experienced the highest levels of euphoria, rating their happiness at 5 out of 5, while those aged 14 to 16 reported a score of 4.5 and 17 to 18-year-olds scored 4.7. In terms of work capacity, the average score was 3.1, with the 17-18 age group showing the highest rating at 3.71 and the 14-16 group the lowest at 2.68. Motivation levels averaged 4.1, peaking at 4.4 among 17-18-year-olds, whereas the 14-16-year-olds displayed no significant increase.
    Conclusion:The findings reveal that younger children are more emotionally responsive to victories, while older adolescents demonstrate greater resilience and utilize positive emotions to enhance their focus and motivation. This underscores the importance of understanding emotional dynamics in sports, providing insights into how to foster resilience, emotional intelligence, and community among young fans and players. By cultivating these qualities, we can support the holistic development of youth, ultimately contributing to their growth as individuals both on and off the field.

    Introduction

    It is known that mood can influence cognitive functions, leading to both improvements and declines in mental or physical performances [1]. Sports activities, both direct participation and support, affect mood, cognitive functions, and even decision-making processes [2].  Spectators' behavior attracts the attention of psychologists. For example, the behavior of spectators during the match and the effects of game outcomes on food Cravings and eating behavior  have been studied, that is, it is different according to losses and wins [3].

    Participation in spectator sports is driven by personal and psychological factors, while external influences involve product and contextual elements. Individual depth of perception is crucial, with external incentives, social influences, and urban context acting as moderating factors. Understanding these perceptions and emotions is essential for fostering greater engagement [4].

    Psychologists try to measure the emotional responses of sports fans during events, capturing feelings like happiness, anger, sadness, and excitement related to their team's performance. This analysis helps teams and marketers understand fan engagement and loyalty, allowing for tailored strategies and enhanced experiences.

    According to "Statista," football is the world's most popular sport, with an annual audience of 4 billion and 250 million active players competing in local and international championships globally. Football is the most popular sport in Europe, and it is not surprising that the European Championship, which is held every 4 years and where all European countries participate, receives a lot of attention [5]. Winning the European Championship is the most difficult, and at the same time, going to the tournament is also prestigious for small nations like Georgia.

    Until 2024, Georgia had never qualified for a major tournament like the European Championship, so it's no surprise that the recent draw against Greece was particularly tense. During this historic match, Georgian fans went through a rollercoaster of emotions.

    From the first half to the penalty shootout, Georgian fans remained steadfast despite the tension. This challenging match showcased their unwavering support for the players until the final whistle. Many underestimate the impact of fans in football; they are often referred to as the "twelfth player" for good reason, as the cheers of the crowd positively influence the psychology of the home team.

    Football, being the most popular sport worldwide, is deeply intertwined with a wide range of emotions experienced by fans. For instance, supporters typically express overwhelming joy and excitement when their favorite team secures a victory. Conversely, during high-stakes moments like a penalty shootout, fans often feel intense stress and nervousness, fully invested in the outcome of each kick. Additionally, when a team fails to capitalize on a promising attack, fans may experience feelings of frustration and dissatisfaction. This emotional connection highlights how integral football is not only to entertainment but also to the psychological landscape of its supporters [6-7].

    For many, watching football serves as a valuable way to relieve stress. Additionally, it fosters friendships among individuals who share a common passion for the sport, whether through a favorite team or player. Watching matches together, often at friends’ homes, helps people bond as they share in the excitement and emotions of the game. Football is not just about the 22 players on the field; it is a powerful medium for connection. The communal experience of supporting a team creates lasting relationships and strengthens social ties, making the sport a significant part of many people's lives [8-9].

    Football not only unites people globally, but it also provides a platform for large companies to promote their brands and advertise their products. A prime example is the strong association between beer and snacks, such as chips, with the sport. This connection is reinforced through advertising and cultural reputation, making these products synonymous with the football experience [3].

    Emotions play a crucial role in shaping our motivation, particularly in our dedication to hard work. Positive feelings like enthusiasm, passion, and determination serve as powerful motivators, driving us to push forward and tackle challenges with energy. These emotions infuse our efforts with a sense of purpose and achievement, reinforcing our resilience in the face of obstacles. When we cultivate positive emotions, we enhance our ability to persist and thrive, transforming challenges into opportunities for growth and success. This connection between emotion and motivation is essential for achieving our goals and maintaining a strong work ethic.

    On the other hand, negative emotions such as stress, anxiety, and frustration can weaken our motivation, leading to feelings of demotivation and impairing our task performance. It's essential to identify and address these emotions, using effective strategies to manage them and sustain our focus and drive. By cultivating positivity and emotional resilience, we can more adeptly overcome challenges and ultimately reach our goals through consistent effort and determination.

    Our study aimed to explore the influence of positive emotions on work capacity and motivation, specifically investigating how the joy of winning a football match affects work capacity, attention, concentration, and motivation immediately afterward in adolesant fans.

    Methods

    The survey was conducted a week after Georgia's historic victory in the final qualifying match for the European Championship, which marked the nation's first-ever trip to the tournament. This momentous win was celebrated as a national event, generating widespread excitement and joy among people of all ages, from children to adults. To capture this shared enthusiasm, the research involved 40 school-aged children, aged 11 to 17.

    We prepared the questions tailored to the age of the research group, and respondents completed them via Google Forms. The first question asked participants to indicate their age, which was categorized into the following intervals: 11-13, 14-16, 17 and 18. 18-year-old persons were excluded from this group, therefore the results of the study were based on the questionnaire filled in by persons under the age of 18 (that is, 7 of the 47 persons participating in the study were excluded, therefore 40 participants remained in the study). Each respondent selected the option that applied to them. Additionally, participants could choose where they watched the match, either "on TV" or "at the stadium."

    For the question "During which period did you worry the most?", respondents could choose from the following options:

    To evaluate the duration of post-match euphoria, respondents were presented with the question, "After the match, how long did you experience feelings of euphoria (characterized by positive emotions and great joy)?" The available response options included:

    This question aimed to gather insights into how long the positive emotions persisted after the match, providing a clearer understanding of the impact of such experiences on overall well-being.

    To investigate the impact of euphoria on work capacity, the reporter conducted a subjective evaluation and selected one of the following responses regarding how euphoria affected their ability to work and study afterward:

    This assessment aimed to capture the extent to which feelings of euphoria influenced daily productivity and academic performance in the days following the event.

    On the second day after the match, to assess the energy changes associated with euphoria, respondents were asked to select one of the following statements:

    This question aimed to explore how the euphoric experience influenced energy levels in the days following the event.

    Respondents were asked to use a ranking scale to evaluate and rate several specific reactions related to their experience of the match and its aftermath. The items for ranking included:

    In this section of the survey, participants were instructed to rank each of these items from 1 to 5, where a ranking of 1 indicated the least significant or impactful indicator, while a ranking of 5 represented the greatest significance. This methodology aimed to provide valuable insights into how various factors influenced their emotional and functional state in the days following the match, enabling a deeper understanding of the overall experience.

    Participants were provided with a questionnaire designed to gauge their emotional responses following the match between Georgia and Greece. The questionnaire asked them to describe their emotional state and, in certain instances, rate their feelings on a scale from 1 to 5. This approach allowed for a nuanced understanding of their emotional experiences. The process of completing the questionnaire was crafted to be engaging and enjoyable, ensuring that responses remained anonymous to encourage honesty. Once collected, the data was subjected to statistical analysis to draw meaningful conclusions about the emotional impact of this historic football match.

    Results

    Children aged 11 to 13 rated their level of euphoria on match night at a perfect 5 on a scale of 1 to 5. Meanwhile, those aged 14 to 16 scored their euphoria at 4.5, while the 17 to 18 age group rated theirs at 4.7, with a statistical significance of p < 0.05 (see Fig. 1).

    Regarding the ability to work the day after the match, participants subjectively rated it on a scale of 1 to 5, resulting in an average score of 3.1. However, significant variations were observed across different age groups. For instance, among the 17 to 18-year-olds, the ability to work was rated the highest at 3.71, while the lowest rating was 2.68 (p < 0.05) for the 14 to 16-year-olds. Children aged 11 to 13 had an average score of 3.45 (see Fig. 2).

    Based on subjective reports, motivation levels on the day after the match averaged 4.1. The highest motivation was observed among the 17 to 18-year-olds, who scored 4.4 points, while the 14 to 16-year-olds reported the lowest motivation (see Fig. 3).

    Discussion

    Football is an active and dynamic sport that captivates millions of people around the world. Whether a person plays on the field or cheers from the sidelines as a spectator, the outcomes of competitions can significantly influence their emotions and behaviors. The excitement and tension that come with each match create an atmosphere charged with feelings that can have lasting effects. Our research delves into how the euphoria generated by winning a football match uniquely affects the emotional states, work capacity, and motivation of children across different age groups.

    The findings from our study reveal some interesting patterns regarding emotional responses to victory. Children aged 11 to 13 emerge as the most exuberant winners, experiencing the highest levels of happiness following a football match. This age group appears particularly vulnerable to positive emotions, suggesting that they have a heightened capacity for joy and excitement. Their immediate reactions to winning are often intense and can significantly enhance their overall sense of well-being. In contrast, children aged 14 to 16 display a greater degree of emotional stability. This group tends to approach the euphoria associated with winning with a more measured perspective, demonstrating a level of resilience that allows them to manage their emotions effectively. As a result, they are relatively resistant to the highs and lows that can accompany match outcomes, reflecting a maturity in how they process emotional experiences.

    When we examine work capacity, a similar trend emerges among the 14 to 16-year-olds. This group shows the least impact from the match results on their ability to work and concentrate the day after a game. Their ability to maintain focus appears to be largely unaffected by the euphoria of victory, indicating that they may possess coping mechanisms that help them compartmentalize their emotions. Conversely, among the 17 to 18 age group, there is a noticeable increase in work capacity following a win. This suggests that older adolescents may utilize the positive emotions generated by a match victory to enhance their productivity and focus, transforming the excitement of the game into motivation for their tasks.

    In terms of motivation levels, our study highlights significant differences across age groups. High motivation scores were observed in both the 11 to 13 and 17 to 18 age categories. Participants in these groups reported increased motivation on the second day after the match compared to other days, indicating that the joy of winning can lead to a surge in enthusiasm for other activities. However, the 14 to 16-year-olds did not experience a similar boost in motivation linked to the euphoria from the match. This lack of response suggests that their emotional reactions to winning may be more subdued, demonstrating a key distinction in how motivation is affected by external events among different developmental stages.

    Overall, our study underscores the varying impacts of match outcomes on children of different ages. While younger children revel in the joy and excitement of winning, older adolescents exhibit a more complex and sophisticated response, leveraging positive emotions to boost their work capacity and motivation. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for creating supportive environments that harness the positive effects of sports on youth development.

    By recognizing and addressing the emotional responses elicited by sporting events, we can better support children and adolescents in navigating their feelings and channeling their enthusiasm into productive outcomes.

    Football offers numerous benefits for children's emotional and social development. Winning can elicit intense joy, particularly among younger players, fostering resilience and enhancing emotional intelligence as they learn to navigate their feelings. Victories can boost motivation, encouraging children and adolescents to engage enthusiastically in other activities, which can enhance their focus and productivity. Additionally, the sport promotes social connections, helping children build friendships and teamwork skills within a supportive community. The physical activity involved also contributes to overall health and well-being, further enriching their developmental experiences.

    Despite its benefits, football can also present challenges for young players. Emotional volatility is common, especially in younger children, who may struggle with intense highs and lows tied to match outcomes, potentially affecting their behavior and mood. The competitive nature of the sport can create pressure to win, leading to stress and anxiety, particularly among those who struggle with losing. Furthermore, the focus on football may detract from academic responsibilities and other interests, while a reliance on external validation from match results can hinder the development of intrinsic motivation. Overall, balancing these emotional responses is essential for healthy growth.

    By fostering this understanding, we can effectively promote resilience, enhance emotional intelligence, and cultivate a strong sense of community among both young fans and players. Encouraging resilience helps children and adolescents learn how to bounce back from setbacks, enabling them to face challenges with confidence and determination. Developing emotional intelligence allows them to better understand and manage their own emotions, as well as empathize with others, which is crucial in both sports and everyday life.

    Moreover, fostering a sense of community brings young people together, creating supportive networks where they can share experiences, celebrate successes, and navigate difficulties together. This collective spirit not only strengthens their bonds but also enriches their engagement with the sport. Ultimately, these elements work in harmony to contribute to the holistic growth and development of young individuals, equipping them with essential life skills that extend far beyond the realm of football. Through such initiatives, we lay the groundwork for a healthier, more connected, and emotionally aware generation.

    We have not found data in the literature on such a study in adolescents in Georgia. The disadvantages of the study can be considered a small sample limited to one team, which does not allow extrapolating the study data to all adolescents.

    Conclusion

    Although football stands as the most popular sport globally, captivating audiences of all ages—including children and adolescents—it is essential to recognize that the euphoria stemming from match outcomes can significantly alter performance and motivation levels in varying ways across different age groups. Our research highlights this intriguing phenomenon, revealing that while the excitement of a victory can inspire joy and enthusiasm, its effects are not uniform among all participants.

    For younger children, the thrill of winning a football match can lead to heightened emotions and a remarkable boost in motivation. This age group often experiences intense joy, which can translate into increased energy and focus in various activities. Their engagement with the sport fosters a sense of belonging and community, reinforcing positive emotional responses that can enhance their overall well-being.

    Authorship

    Сonceptualization, writing, data collection and analysis –Dondoladze K.,

    Editing – Miraleyeva A.

    Acknowledgment

    We would like to extend our heartfelt gratitude to Sandro Gogeshvili, a student at the New School, for his invaluable assistance in collecting data from adolescents for our research. His dedication and support were instrumental in the success of this study, and we greatly appreciate his contributions.

    Conflict of interest

    The authors confirm that there is no conflict of interest

     

    Figure 1. Level of Happiness on the Night of the Match Victory

    Figure 2. Impact of Match Victory Euphoria on Work Capacity the Following Day

    Figure 3. Influence of Match Victory Euphoria on Motivation the Following Day

    Dondoladze K. - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1458-8912

    Miraleyeva A. - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3251-5645

    References:

    1. Lagner, P., Kliegel, M., Phillips, L. H., Ihle, A., Hering, A., Ballhausen, N., & Schnitzspahn, K. M. (2015). Mood effects on memory and executive control in a real-life situation. Cognition & emotion, 29(6), 1107–1116. https://doi.org/10.1080/02699931.2014.962486
    2. Angit A. D., Connelly S., Waples E. P., Kligyte V. (2011). The influence of discrete emotions on judgement and decision-making: a meta-analytic review. Cognit. Emot. 25, 1393–1422. doi: 10.1080/02699931.2010.550751, PMID: - DOI PubMed
    3. Chang Y. (2021). Effects of Game Situation-Dependent Emotions on Sport Spectators' Food Craving. Frontiers in psychology, 12, 724220. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.724220
    4. Wang, F., Zhou, J., & Fan, C. (2024). Exploring the factors influencing public intention for spectator sports consumption based on grounded theory. Scientific reports, 14(1), 8221. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-59049-9
    5. Pandit, Rupa (2022). Physical Education: Textbook for ICSE Class 10. Oswal Publishers. ISBN 978-93-90278-47-3.
    6. McKee, A. C., Daneshvar, D. H., Alvarez, V. E., & Stein, T. D. (2014). The neuropathology of sport. Acta neuropathologica, 127(1), 29–51. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00401-013-1230-6
    7. Meyer, T., Demond, V., & Scharhag, J. (2022). Cardiocirculatory Stress in Professional Football (Soccer) Coaches. Clinical journal of sport medicine : official journal of the Canadian Academy of Sport Medicine, 32(4), 414–417. https://doi.org/10.1097/JSM.0000000000001013;
    8. Wegmann, M., Steffen, A., Pütz, K., Würtz, N., Such, U., Faude, O., Bohm, P., & Meyer, T. (2016). Cardiovascular risk and fitness in veteran football players. Journal of sports sciences, 34(6), 576–583. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2015.1118525
    9. Tušak, M., Corrado, D. D., Coco, M., Tušak, M., Žilavec, I., & Masten, R. (2022). Dynamic Interactive Model of Sport Motivation. International journal of environmental research and public health, 19(7), 4202. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19074202

    Additional files